top rounded corners
pad
  • Increase font size
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
pad
Seach Sponsored by Pizza Hut Hawaii
pad
KGMB9 Weekend Team
Kahului Harbor Plan Controversy Print E-mail
Written by Lisa Kubota - lkubota@kgmb9.com   
January 23, 2008 09:53 PM

 
After Maui's Superferry saga there is a new struggle over the future of Kahului Harbor.

Some fear millions of dollars worth of improvements by the state will wipe out several popular surf spots. The changes are part of the Kahului Harbor 2030 Master Plan.

A public meeting on the draft environmental impact statement was held in Wailuku on Wednesday night. Both sides agreed the expansion is badly needed but they had different ideas about what should be done.

Space is tight in Kahului at the third busiest harbor in the state. Cargo is crowded. Cruise ships and the Superferry need more room.

"It's the busiest neighbor island harbor. They only have three piers and they've outgrown their capacity probably as of two or three years ago," said Michael Formby, deputy director of the state Department of Transportation's Harbors Division.

The state hopes to fix the problem with its 2030 Master Plan which contains two alternatives.

Both require dredging and extending concrete structures called breakwaters that weaken waves heading into the harbor.

Alternative A calls for a new facility at the west breakwater for cruise ships and the inter-island ferry.

Pier 1 and 2 would be expanded for cargo. Alternative B would develop passenger facilities at Pier 2 and expand Piers 1 and 3 along with the west breakwater for cargo.

Groups like the Maui Sierra Club and Save Kahului Harbor disliked both ideas. One of their main concerns was the impact on surf spots. State officials admitted the changes will affect some of the surfing sites.

"There are many, many problems with safety and just practicality. They are fast-tracking it and ignoring these problems," said Karen Chun, a spokesperson for Save Kahului Harbor and the Sierra Club.

"If they come forward, put their concerns on the table, we have an opportunity to mitigate the impact to the recreational interests as much as possible," Formby said.

Opponents said paddling should not be labeled as recreation but as a key cultural practice. They also worried the plan would make the turning basin used by tugboats unsafe.

"We can come up with a plan that expands the harbor outward which really does set us up for 2030 instead of inward. Basically, they're not looking at what's best for Maui," Chun said.

"I think what we try to do is accommodate the commercial interests and at the same time have as little impact on the recreational interests as we can," Formby said.

The cost estimates are $390 million for Alternative A and $359 million for Alternative B.



Twitter!Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Fark!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!
Last Updated ( January 23, 2008 09:53 PM )
 

Sunrise on KGMB9

Sunrise on KGMB9
Weekdays 4:30-8am

Have you heard? Dan Cooke is joining the Sunrise crew as the new Weather Anchor! Dan will be here later this summer. Until then, Malika Dudley and Ben Gutierrez will share the Sunrise weather responsibilities - weekday mornings on the 9s!

Wake Up With Us

KGMB9.com Interactive

Storm Patrol
KGMB9's Storm Patrol

Be a part of KGMB9's Storm Patrol and tell us the weather in your neighborhood. We want video and pictures straight from you.

Join the Team

KGMB9.com on Twitter

Follow KGMB9.com on Twitter
KGMB9.com is now on Twitter

KGMB9 Interactive has been meaning to write up something to explain what Twitter is and why we have been using it.

Follow KGMB9.com

hawaii.womf.com

hawaii.womf.com
Hawaii's New
Word of Mouth Forum

Have a favorite local business or service? Share your experiences with them on the new Word of Mouth Forum and help Hawaii's businesses thrive in this challenging economy.

Make Your Voice Heard

KGMB9 News

Why Did the Anchor Cross the Road?
Tannya Joaquin Joins
KGMB9 News at 5 & 6

KGMB9 welcomes Tannya Joaquin the anchor desk weeknights at 5 & 6 p.m. Still curious on why the anchor crossed the road? Let Tannya explain...

Find Out!

bottom rounded corners